Sweet meets salty with this pretzel toffee ice cream made in your Ninja Creami. Crunchy, creamy and packed with rich toffee and salty pretzel goodness!

A cup of vanilla ice cream topped with caramel sauce and crushed pretzels, surrounded by whole pretzels and butterscotch chips on a wooden surface. A silver spoon with a bit of ice cream rests nearby.

There’s nothing better than a creamy, crunchy, sweet, and salty treat that also packs a protein punch! If you’re looking for a recipe that satisfies all your cravings while keeping things on the healthier side, this Pretzel Toffee Protein Ice Cream is the perfect solution.

It’s got that smooth, creamy texture we love in homemade ice cream, plus the irresistible combination of crunchy pretzels, rich toffee bits, and a drizzle of caramel. Whether you’re a Ninja Creami pro or just diving into taking your first spin, this recipe will quickly become a favorite!

A cup of creamy vanilla ice cream topped with caramel drizzle and crushed pretzel pieces. A spoon with remnants of ice cream is on the wooden surface, surrounded by scattered whole pretzels and caramel bits.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

If you’ve ever found yourself torn between a salty snack and a sweet treat, this recipe gives you the best of both worlds! The creamy delight of the ice cream pairs perfectly with crunchy pretzels and rich toffee bits. Plus, it’s made with simple ingredients like a protein shake, meaning you can enjoy a delicious treat while still hitting your nutrition goals.

A spoonful of creamy dessert topped with caramel and small pretzel pieces, held over a cup filled with the same dessert. Scattered pretzels and caramel bits are visible on the wooden table surface.

Whether you use almond milk, coconut milk, or the classic Premier Protein shake, you’ll get a smooth, satisfying dessert without the guilt of traditional ice cream. Best of all, it’s quick and easy to make with your Ninja Creami ice cream maker—no traditional ice cream maker required!

Ingredients

Vanilla Premier Protein shake – the creamy, protein-packed base for this ice cream. You can substitute with Fairlife milk if you want.
Instant vanilla pudding mix – helps create that creamy texture without the need for heavy cream.
Toffee extract – adds a rich, buttery toffee flavor to the ice cream base. You can sub with vanilla extract in a pinch.

Mix ins:

Pretzels, crushed – brings that salty crunch to balance out the sweetness.
Heath toffee bits – enhances the caramelized, buttery flavor in every bite.
Caramel syrup – a finishing touch for extra indulgence.

A clear plastic container filled with frothy, pale liquid on a light wooden surface. The liquid has a bubbly texture, resembling a milkshake or smoothie.

Instructions

1. Combine the Vanilla Premier Protein shake, pudding mix, and toffee extract in the Ninja Creami pint container. Stir well to combine.
2. Freeze the pint container on a flat, level surface for 24 hours or until frozen solid.
3. When ready to serve, run the frozen pint under hot water for 30 seconds to loosen the sides. Remove the lid and place the container into the outer bowl of the Ninja Creami.
4. Secure the outer bowl lid, insert it into the Ninja Creami machine, and press the Lite Ice Cream button. Let the cycle complete.
5. Check the texture; if powdery, use the Re-spin function for a much creamier texture.

A food processor containing a mixture of crumbled pretzels and butterscotch chips is set on a wooden surface. Surrounding the processor are scattered pretzel pieces and butterscotch chips, creating a messy, inviting scene.

6. Create a hole in the center of the ice cream and add the crushed pretzels and toffee bits. Use the Mix-In button to evenly distribute them throughout the entire pint.

A jar of creamy ice cream with visible chunks sits on a wooden surface, surrounded by scattered pretzels and small caramel bits. The dip looks partially consumed, revealing its texture and ingredients.

7. Top with caramel sauce and enjoy!

A clear cup filled with salted caramel ice cream topped with caramel sauce and crushed pretzels. Surrounding the cup are more mini pretzels and caramel chips scattered on a wooden surface. A spoon with ice cream rests beside the cup.

Tips & Tricks

Want ultra-creamy ice cream? Add ½ teaspoon xanthan gum before freezing to maintain the creamy texture. This can be substituted for the pudding mix.
Chop mix-ins into small pieces so they distribute evenly and blend smoothly for the best results.
Place the pint on a flat surface in your freezer to prevent freezing at an angle and ensure an even texture.
If the ice cream is too hard, use the Re-spin function for a softer consistency.
Let the frozen pint sit at room temperature for 10-15 minutes or run it under hot water for 30 seconds before spinning to prevent icy chunks.
If a dome forms on top while freezing, try freezing without the lid or scrape off any excess before spinning to protect your blades.
If you’re looking to reduce the amount of sugar, consider using natural sweeteners like honey, maple syrup, or agave nectar for a different flavor profile.

A glass jar filled with creamy ice cream topped with crushed pretzels and caramel sauce, placed on a wooden surface. Pretzel pieces and caramel bits are scattered around, and a spoon with ice cream rests nearby.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a different protein shake for this recipe?

Absolutely! While Vanilla Premier Protein gives the best flavor and consistency, you can use almond milk, coconut milk, or any other protein shake of your choice. Just be sure to keep the total liquid around 1 ½ cups for the perfect ice cream base.

What’s the best way to get a super creamy texture?

For the best Ninja Creami results, make sure your ice cream base is well-mixed before freezing and use the Re-spin function if needed. Adding a thickener like xanthan gum or instant pudding mix will also help create a much creamier texture.

Can I add chocolate chips or other toppings?

Of course! This recipe is totally customizable. Chocolate chips, chopped nuts, or even a tablespoon of honey can make this creamy treat even more indulgent. Just be sure to add them during the Mix-In cycle for even distribution.

A spoon holds a portion of ice cream mixed with caramel swirls and pretzel pieces over a clear cup. Additional pretzel bits are scattered on the wooden surface.

This Pretzel Toffee Protein Ice Cream is the perfect blend of sweet, salty, and creamy. Whether it’s your first time using the Ninja Creami or you’re a pro looking for new ninja creami recipes to try, this one is sure to be a hit.

Give it a spin and enjoy a homemade ice cream that’s both delicious and packed with protein!

A clear bowl filled with creamy pretzel toffee ice cream topped with pretzel pieces and caramel drizzle. Background shows scattered pretzels. Text overlay reads, Pretzel Toffee Ninja Creami.

If you love this pretzel toffee protein ice cream recipe, please click on the stars below to give it a five star rating and help me share it on Facebook or Pinterest!