This Cookie Monster ice cream is a cool blue, cookie-loaded dream. Made in the Ninja Creami, it’s creamy, crunchy and packed with sweet cookie goodness!

A bowl of pale blue ice cream mixed with chocolate chunks and cookie dough pieces, set on a light wooden surface. Some chocolate and cookie dough pieces are scattered around the bowl, with a spoonful of ice cream beside it.

If you’re a fan of creamy treats and high-protein desserts, this Cookie Monster Protein Ninja Creami recipe is about to become your new obsession! This sweet treat has all the indulgent flavors of cookies and cream while packing a protein punch.

With just a few simple ingredients, you can create a delicious treat that feels like an indulgence but is actually a healthier alternative to traditional ice cream. Whether you’re part of the Ninja Creami community or just trying it out for the first time, this recipe will give you the best results every time.

Too busy to make this right away? Pin it for later! Pin this post to your favorite board on Pinterest and it will be there when you’re ready!

A cup of cookie monster ice cream, topped with crumbled cookies and chocolate chip dough pieces. A spoon is dipped into the creamy dessert, with a wooden surface visible in the background.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

This homemade ice cream is a game changer for anyone looking to enjoy a delicious treat without the guilt. With a protein-packed ice cream base, this recipe offers a much creamier texture than other light ice creams.

A close-up of a spoon holding a scoop of cookie monster ice cream above an open container. The creamy ice cream is pale green with chocolate chunks. Chocolate pieces and nuts are scattered on a wooden surface in the background.

The best part? You get to control the amount of sugar and type of sweetener you use! Plus, the combination of Oreos and cookie dough as mix-ins makes every bite absolutely irresistible.

If you’re looking for a fun, easy way to enjoy protein ice cream, this is it!

Ingredients

Vanilla Premier Protein shake – serves as the creamy, high-protein ice cream base. Milk can be substituted but won’t have the same protein boost.
Instant vanilla pudding mix – adds a smooth, thick texture to the entire pint.
Blue food coloring – gives the ice cream that signature Cookie Monster color.

Mix ins:

Oreos, crumbled – adds a delicious crunch and chocolatey goodness.
Cookie dough, store-bought or homemade – creates a sweet, chewy contrast to the creamy texture. Just makes sure that store bought cookie dough is safe to eat raw.

Check out my cookie dough protein ice cream for the homemade cookie dough recipe.

A top-down view of a clear glass filled with a frothy, light blue liquid. The glass is placed on a light wooden surface.

Instructions

1. Combine vanilla Premier Protein, pudding mix, vanilla extract, and food coloring in the Ninja Creami pint container. Stir well.

2. Freeze the pint container on a flat surface for 24 hours or until frozen solid.

3. Run the frozen pint under hot water for 30 seconds to loosen the sides. Remove the lid and place the container into the outer bowl of the Ninja Creami.
4. Secure the outer bowl lid, insert it into the Ninja Creami machine, and press the Lite Ice Cream button. Let the cycle complete.
5. Check the texture; if powdery, use the Re-spin function for a smoother consistency.

A ninja creami cup filled with light blue ice cream, topped with cookie dough chunks and crushed chocolate cookies. Additional cookie crumbs and dough pieces are scattered on the light wooden surface around it.

6. Create a hole in the center of the ice cream and add Oreos and cookie dough. Use the Mix-In button to evenly distribute.

A jar filled with light blue, creamy ice cream sprinkled with chocolate bits. A spoon is dipped into the dip. Around the jar are scattered pieces of chocolate cookies and small round chocolate chip cookie dough bites on a wooden surface.

7. Top with more cookies and enjoy!

A top view of a bowl containing light blue ice cream mixed with chunks of cookies and small pieces of cookie dough. A gold spoon is in the bowl. Crushed cookies and dough pieces are scattered on the wooden surface around it.

Tips & Tricks

Want ultra-creamy frozen yogurt? Add ½ teaspoon xanthan gum before freezing to maintain texture. This can be substituted for the pudding mix.
Chop mix-ins into small pieces so they distribute evenly and blend smoothly.
Place the pint on a flat surface in your freezer to prevent freezing at an angle.
If the ice cream is too hard, use the Re-spin function for a softer consistency.
Let the frozen pint sit at room temperature for 10-15 minutes or run under hot water for 30 seconds before spinning to prevent icy chunks.
If a dome forms on top while freezing, try freezing without the lid or scrape off any excess before spinning to protect your blades.
If you’re looking to reduce sugar content, consider using natural sweeteners like honey, maple syrup, or agave nectar for a different flavor profile.

Be sure to check out my Guide to Perfect Ninja Creami Recipes for more tips, FAQs and troubleshooting.

A spoon holding a scoop of cookies and cream ice cream with chocolate chunks, above an open container. Crumbled cookies and cookie dough pieces are scattered on a wooden surface around the container.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a different type of protein shake instead of Premier Protein?

Yes! You can substitute with almond milk, coconut milk, or any high-protein shake of your choice, but the texture may vary slightly.

My ice cream turned out icy. How can I fix it?

Try adding a splash of milk or using the Re-spin function to create a much creamier texture.

Can I make this without a Ninja Creami ice cream maker?

While the Ninja Creami gives the best results, you can try blending and refreezing in a traditional ice cream maker, but the texture will be different.

A spoonful of mint chocolate chip ice cream with cookie crumbles and chocolate chunks is being lifted from a container. Scattered cookie pieces and chocolate chips are on the wooden surface around the container.

This Cookie Monster Protein Ninja Creami recipe is proof that homemade ice cream can be both delicious and nutritious. With the right mix-ins and simple ingredients, you can whip up a creamy delight that satisfies your sweet tooth while fueling your body.

Whether it’s your first spin or your second spin, this recipe guarantees a creamy texture and the perfect serving size every time. Now grab your favorite toppings and enjoy every bite of this protein-packed frozen dessert!

Looking for more inspiration? Explore my huge library of delicious and healthy Ninja Creami Recipes. Or join our Ninja Creami Community on Facebook!

A bowl of Cookie Monster ice cream made with the Ninja Creami, featuring blue ice cream mixed with chocolate chunks and cookie pieces. The background has scattered cookie bits. Text on top reads Cookie Monster Ninja Creami.

If you love this cookie monster protein ice cream recipe, please click on the stars below to give it a five star rating and help me share it on Facebook or Pinterest!